SLAVES TO HAPPINESS & PLEASURE
*****
BREAKOUT ONE:
Issa, a native of Mali, now only vaguely remembers his family. He only just remembers the promise of a bike and an education once his parents safely saw him cross the border into Cote d’Ivoire and into the hands of one of the many locateurs (or traffickers) operating in the dusty town of Niele. The promise of an additional $US150 to help out his impoverished family was an added incentive to see him happily make his way, via the locaueur to Le Gros’ (the Big Man’s) farm somewhere deep inside the Ivorian lowland jungles.
He can’t remember exactly how long he’s been on the farm and he has no real idea that he toils for 12-14 hours a day tending the delicate cocoa pods, then extricating the seeds, drying them in the sun, then bagging and carrying and loading them onto trucks for transport to the coast for export.
But Issa craves for something better to eat that the burnt, rotting bananas he and his fellow child slaves on his farm subsist on. And at night – after the beatings, after shoeless toil, after the countless insect bites – he’s locked into an airless, windowless single-room slab hunt measuring barely 7m by 8m . . . along with his 18 other teenage ‘inmates’. No bed. No Netting. No toilet. Just the bare boards.
Issa doesn’t dare contemplate escape. The last youth who tried was tracked for several days through the jungle before being dragged back, exhausted, and bashed to within an inch of his life with chains and tree branches. That young man still drags his left leg somewhat limply – but is expected to work as hard as the others . . .
Welcome to the basis of much of the world’s chocolate trade. But not 300 years ago. Not 100 years ago. Not even 50 years ago. Issa, along with countless thousands of other child slaves is toiling away right now, in 2009. Just to support the global trade of affordable chocolate . . .
****
MAIN FEATURE:
With almost 70 per cent of all world cocoa coming from west Africa (according to the UN), modern-day child slavery is built into most of the world’s chocolate supply. The only exceptions are ethically sustainable, organic chocolates manufactured by a small handful of major players and a growing army of smaller producers.
All this African production comes from only four countries – Cote d’Ivoire (38-39 per cent), Ghana (21-22 per cent), Nigeria (about 5 per cent) and Cameroon (another 5 per cent). All four are no shrinking violets when it comes to human rights abuses, torture and misery. Almost all other cocoa comes from Central and South America and South-East Asia.
Although cocoa forms the bottom rung of the world’s commodity price ladder – traded on two exchanges (London and New York) – millions of poor families in third-world countries depend on it for their livelihoods. Cocoa is the world’s smallest soft-commodity market. Some 5 million families produce the global output of 3.6 million tonnes a year. The London commodities exchange handles most of the west African production.
But Cote d’Ivoire produces the most globally, generating some 20 per cent of its income from cocoa – and making the issue of slavery all the more pressing. According to the International Labor Organisation more than 109,000 children were working on Ivorian cocoa farms in 2002, but this number had risen to about 200,000 three years later. By now, it could be almost as high as 300,000. No one is sure . . . What we do know is that so many of these children work in some of the most appalling conditions imaginable.
Given the delicacy of cocoa pods – they have to be grown in the steamy dappled under-storey jungle light – crops are often subjected to huge doses of chemical pesticides, many of which have been banned elsewhere. Farmers, their families and the slaves are all exposed, without protective clothing or gloves. Yet despite these efforts, as much as 30 per cent of all Cote d’Ivoire cocoa crops can be lost to disease in any one year.
The plight of the country’s child slaves first came to mainstream light 11 years ago, when it was estimated that as many as 6 per cent of children toiling on that country’s crops were being trafficked from neighbouring countries – Ghana, Burkina Faso, Liberia, Mali, Guinea, Benin and Togo. That was 12,000 children. UNICEF puts the total number of children trafficked throughout west Africa at a staggering 200,000 a year. The BBC has reported that as many as 12,000 children a year are being trafficked from Mali alone into Cote d’Ivoire every year. Cote d’Ivoire traffickers are being paid as little as $US10 per child they deliver to Le Gros.
Sadly, Anti-Slavery International estimates as many as 700,000 women and children are trafficked each year around the world in a squalid trade estimated to be worth about $US7 billion.
News of how chocolate made from Ivorian beans could be linked to child slavery caused immediate outrage. There was an attempt by several United States senators to add an amendment to the 2001 Agricultural Appropriations bill that would require chocolate products to carry labelling confirming that slaves were not used in producing their cocoa. However, the chocolate industry protested: the action would cause consumers to boycott chocolate products, which would only hurt the cocoa producers even more. The twisted logic was that the less revenue they received, the more these growers might continue using slaves.
The bill never reached the House-Senate conference committee, as the US chocolate industry joined forces to take “action” regarding the elimination of child labor on cocoa farms. This successfully precluded any official government action.
But nothing much has changed. Cote d’Ivoire’s internal political situation isn’t helping either. Political unrest is rampant, there have been two coups (1999 and 2001), and civil war has been raging for two years – ironically over prime cocoa-growing areas.
Just as it’s hard to put a figure on the amount of global cocoa that’s produced by slaves, it’s just as hard to estimate the amount of slave product coming out of Cote d’Ivoire alone. And when Cote d’Ivoire cocoa beans are mixed with production from other countries as far afield as Belize and Indonesia – then onsold to traders via the two major exchanges – the task becomes tragically impossible to calculate.
Suffice to say, though, there’s an excellent chance that any chocolate not made using cocoa sourced directly from farmers on a Fairtrade basis is tainted by slavery.
But even when child slaves aren’t used in cocoa production, the International Program On The Elimination of Child Labor and the ILO estimate that most family members involved in the industry around the world earn as little as $US30-110 each a year – a pittance compared with the overall commercial value of chocolate.
It’s hard to comprehend the disparity when Americans gorge themselves on more than $US13 billion worth of chocolate products each year.
Nor is it easy to align a product so often associated with our pleasure and happiness with such gross, rampant human misery.
1) Estimation of global slavery today – Expendable People: Slavery in the Age of Globalisation – Kevin Bales
*****
COCOA – A DELICIOUS STORY
(SIDEBAR 2):
But not all west African cocoa is produced in dreadful conditions. In 1993, when the government liberalised Ghana’s cocoa trade, thousands of the country’s farmers – fearing their industry would be over-run by foreign interests – formed the Kuapa Kokoo co-operative.
Like so many cocoa farmers around the world, many of these people had not only never tasted chocolate before the co-op, they didn’t even know what it was!
Soon after forming the co-operative, they struck an agreement with Germany’s Divine chocolate company to buy their cocoa at Fairtrade prices.
Today, some 45,000 farmers are Kuapa Kokoo members. Company sales in 2007 were more than $US18 million, and Divine – which sells its Fairtrade-branded product “not at super-premium prices” – bought 1200 tonnes of Kuapa Kokoo cocoa in the same year.
However, 98 per cent of the co-op’s production is sold to the state-run marketing board, so ends up in many different chocolate brands around the world.
Coming full circle, the Kuapa Kokoo co-operative now owns 45 per cent of Divine, allowing it to share in the company’s overall profits as well.
Sweet!
CHOCOHOLICS
(SIDEBAR 3)
Although cocoa is largely produced in developing countries, it is mostly consumed in industrialised countries.
For cocoa, the buyers in the consuming countries are the processors and the chocolate manufacturers. A few multinational companies dominate both sides of the mechanised business, and market the final product.
According to the UN, the largest consumers of chocolate are:
· The United States – about 33 per cent
· Germany – almost 12 per cent
· France – almost 10.5 per cent
· Britain – more than 9 per cent
Interestingly, the Japanese – who didn’t know much about chocolate before World War II – now consume almost 4.5 per cent of all that’s made in the world.